Five Reasons You May Need To Change Your Prop

By Charles Fort

Selecting the proper prop for the job is a matter of listening to what your boat is telling you.

A member in Jacksonville, Florida, had just purchased an aging 25-foot fishing boat with twin 200-hp outboards. As sometimes happens with a "new" boat, it didn't take long before one of the engines — the starboard engine — began making a strange noise. He shut it down and returned home with the port engine.

The noise was traced to a wrist pin, which had come loose and wrecked a cylinder. The engine had only a few hundred hours on the meter. After repairs, which were not covered by insurance, had been completed, the mechanic took the boat out for a sea trial and concluded the engines were lugging because the prop's pitch was too high. It was the stress of pushing the prop, he said, that had damaged the wrist pins. The surveyor noted that the problem was certain to recur if the same propellers were used.

PropPic 18 TMAG Winter2012 2.jpg

Everybody knows to change the engine oil, swap out the impeller every year or two, and change belts, but the prop is much more likely to be overlooked. Choosing the wrong prop, or continuing to use a prop that is damaged, can not only cause your boat to perform poorly, it can increase fuel consumption and even damage your engine and transmission. Here are five conditions that warrant a closer look at your prop.

1. Is your boat slow to come onto plane?

If your propeller has too much pitch (see sidebar) like the one above, the engine will have a lousy "hole shot" — the ability to get on plane quickly — and will lug. You wouldn’t want to leave from a stoplight with your car in third gear; not only would it take much longer to accelerate, the engine would be working hard at low speeds, which places a tremendous load on the pistons, crankshaft, and bearings. This in turn can cause detonation, piston seizure, and other engine damage. If your engine can’t get to within 100-200 rpm of rated wide open throttle (WOT), you probably have a prop issue, assuming your engine runs fine and there is not a lot of growth on the hull. Most props can have the pitch adjusted at a prop shop, which can save having to buy a new one. A general rule of thumb is that a one-inch pitch change will result in a 175-225 rpm change at WOT.

2. Does your engine over-rev and the boat seem slow?

If your propeller has too little pitch, the engine can rev past its red-line, which is like driving your car on the interstate in second gear. Continuous running past WOT will soon damage an engine. A prop shop can add more pitch or recommend a new prop. Notice that having either too little or too much pitch can cause engine damage. So why don't all boats come with the right prop in the first place? They may have but the prop could have been changed later. A boatbuilder doesn’t know how or where you will be using your boat and often uses a compromise prop. Running your boat at high-altitude lakes, for example, requires a different prop than on a boat that will be used at sea level. A boat used to pull skiers or one that is loaded down with weekend gear will require a different prop than a boat used for zooming a couple of fishermen out to a fishing spot.

3. Did you run over a log, hit a sandbar or a rock?

A bent blade or nick will severely affect performance and could even damage the engine and transmission. Note that a bad prop doesn’t always look bad. Larry Carlson at Black Dog Props in Stevensville, Maryland, which uses computers to repair props, says that 80 percent of the propellers on his shop floor look healthy. But those otherwise "healthy" looking propellers typically have differences in pitch of one-half inch to three-fourths inch.

Speaking of bent props, what material is best for a prop? A lot depends on where you do your boating. If your chances of hitting a submerged object are low, an aluminum prop is an inexpensive choice. Most manufacturers install aluminum props, but they're far less rugged than more expensive stainless-steel props.

4. Do you want your boat to be faster?

The first place to look is the prop. As a rule, a stainless-steel prop (assuming the correct pitch and diameter) will make your boat go faster — up to 2-3 knots on some boats. Stainless steel is stronger and can be made thinner, allowing more speed. Stainless steel also flexes less and keeps its shape at higher speeds. The downside to stainless-steel props is cost, about three times more than an aluminum prop, and more expensive repairs. Also, in a severe strike, they may cause drivetrain damage because they won't deform as easily.

5. Using too much fuel?

It might be your prop. A dinged and bent prop can rob you of 10 percent of your fuel costs. Prop shops can use a machine to tell how far out of specification your prop might be, and repair it like new. They can also advise as to whether you might need a prop of a different diameter. Diameter and pitch are interrelated, and sometimes getting the right prop for the best efficiency is as much art as science and might require trying several different props.End of story marker

Chuck Fort is Associate Editor of Seaworthy, the BoatUS Marine Insurance damage-avoidance publication, which is filled with useful boating safety advice and lessons learned, and free to all BoatUS members. For an insurance quote, please call 1-800-283-2883 or apply online at www.BoatUS.com.


Get Peace Of Mind With TowBoatUS

Got prop, engine, or general worries about getting stuck out on the water? Now's a great time to buy BoatUS Towing. We've got a fleet of 600 TowBoatUS and VESSEL ASSIST towboats servicing over 300 ports with a 24-Hour Dispatch Service. For more information www.BoatUS.com/towing


Recommended Articles
Gray rule

PropellerSelecting The Right Propeller

Use these tips to find the best propellor for your engine



Stuffing boxServicing Your Stuffing Box

On inboard engines, the stuffing box provides a seal for the propellor shaft, but it needs to be properly adjusted


Outboard enginePreventing Problems in Outboard Motors

Installation is important also the condition of the propeller, gasoline and motor oil

 


Important Definitions

  • Diameter: An important factor in thrust — the larger the diameter of the prop, everything else being equal, the more water that gets moved. As a general rule, when performance suffers, you change pitch and not diameter. Diameter is the first number listed in a prop size, such as 14x17.
  • Pitch and Slippage: Pitch is the distance a prop moves through the water in one revolution. The second number stamped on the prop is pitch. A prop with a pitch of 18 inches would move 18 inches through a solid medium with each complete rotation. The reason a propeller moves something less than 18 inches is because it operates in a liquid medium, which creates slippage. So instead of moving 18 inches, a propeller in water moves maybe 15 inches. Some slippage is essential; without it, the prop can't move the boat, but too much or too little slippage reduces efficiency.
  • Rotation: Propellers can rotate to the right (clockwise when viewed from astern) or the left (counterclockwise). Most outboard and I/O propellers rotate to the right. Many sterndrives have two counter-rotating props.
  • Number of Blades: More blades are smoother but slightly less efficient. The typical compromise is three blades, although four blades are becoming increasingly more popular.
  • Thickness: Blades should be as thin as possible, since it takes more power to turn a thick blade. Stainless propellers are five times stronger than aluminum, which is why they can be thinner and still retain adequate strength. Hence, stainless-steel props are more efficient.

 

BoatUS Magazine Is A Benefit Of BoatUS Membership

Membership Also Provides:

  • Subscription to the print version of BoatUS Magazine
  • 4% back on purchases from West Marine stores or online at WestMarine.com
  • Discounts on fuel, transient slips, repairs and more at over 1,000 businesses
  • Deals on cruises, charters, car rentals, hotel stays and much more ...
  • All For Only $24 A Year!


Join Today!