Print article Foundation Findings 45 FLare Testing  
Flares Revisted
The Shopping List for Flare Testing
Parachute Flares
Aerial Flare Options
Pistol-style Flare Guns
Pocket Sized aerial options
Smoke Flare Options
Handheld Flares  
The Common Handheld  
Now That's Hot - SOLAS Handhelds  
Bright and Sparkly non-approved handhelds  
Non-Pyrotechnic distress signals  
Final Thoughts about Flares  
Photo Gallery
Get in on the sction from our testing day with more videos
 
Foundation Findings #44 - Boarding Ladders

Now That's Hot - SOLAS Handhelds

Pains Wessex Red Hand Flare MK8 - SOLAS
Comet Red Handflare – SOLAS

The Pains Wessex and Comet (same manufacturer) red hand flares differ in only the directions printed on the side of the flares. The color pictograms on the Pains Wessex version were much easier to read and follow than the simple black text found on the Comet.

This is a very compact hand flare consisting of a metal tube that holds the flare, and a plastic outer housing that telescopes down prior to the ignition process. The plastic surface had a ribbed hand hold just like the SOLAS parachute and white handheld flare models. The metal tube does not melt/burn down like the Orion Handheld after activation. With this design the flare contents are burned only at the tip of the flare and this results in a greatly reduced amount of slag. However, the metal tube becomes white hot during activation and we found it necessary to cool them in the water for several minutes before disposing.

Orion Red Handheld Flare – SOLAS

The Orion SOLAS red handheld model is different from the Orion USCG approved model in design. A long handle extends the ignition tip farther away from the hand. Like the other SOLAS models the flare does not burn down to the handle but only at the top end of the flare. This flare burns with more of a yellow/orange color, as opposed to the red found in the Pains-Wessex models. Coupled with the fact that it also produced less smoke than the Pains-Wessex models, the Orion version was deemed to be inferior to the Pains-Wessex for daytime use.

Click to go to the next page of the Foundation Findings report

The SOLAS handhelds were a bit easier to spot from shore because they produced a lot of smoke.
The SOLAS handhelds were a bit easier to spot from shore because they produced a lot of smoke.
At night the SOLAS handhelds were too bright to look at on the boat.
At night the SOLAS handhelds were too bright to look at on the boat.
They almost made the boat look like it was on fire
They almost made the boat look like it was on fire.
 
©2007-2008, BoatUS Foundation for Boating Safety and Clean Water