The Outward Hound was a consistent performer in every category and earned high marks regardless of the size dog we fitted. Not only was it a good all around jacket, it was also a great value starting at $15.99 for small dogs to $28.99 for extra large dogs.

The Outward Hound was the only jacket that had all the features we desired in a flotation device for dogs. For starters, the fit was good because of generous Velcro closures and segmented flotation panels. The jacket also had a nice neoprene panel for the underbelly and the adjustment straps secured over it so that the straps never come in direct contact with the dog.

The flotation is distributed evenly and keeps the dogs horizontal in the water. The collar, which features integral flotation, aids in keeping the dog's head and muzzle up and also has the secondary benefit of preventing the jacket from working aft on the dog. The use of Velcro also prevents the jacket from loosening once it becomes wet. However, some dog owners commented that the Velcro tended to attract shedding hair.

The orange Outward Hound (comes in neon green too) is actually quite stylish with silver reflective piping so that it can be seen easily day or night. The Outward Hound also has sensible strap adjustments, simple buckles and a padded lifting handle. On land, dogs moved with ease and prompted one owner to exclaim that this jacket was a "simple, smart fit" and another owner to declare, "This is the jacket I would purchase." For these reasons and because it is available at many big box pet stores, this jacket earned the designation of Staff Pick.